Homemade Soda Shop in Rexburg, Idaho: An Old-School Ice Cream Experience at Rinky Dinks
If you’ve been looking for a homemade soda shop in Rexburg, Idaho, there’s one place that actually feels different — Rinky Dinks.
It’s the only spot in town making soda in-house, and it pairs that with an old-school ice cream parlor feel that’s honestly hard to find in Rexburg.
A Homemade Soda Shop in Rexburg That’s Actually Different
What stood out right away was the soda.
This isn’t your typical “dirty soda” setup. Rinky Dinks is the only place in Rexburg making homemade soda in-house, and you can tell the difference.
The flavors feel more balanced, more unique, and just better overall.
You’ll find:
- Custom soda combinations
- Creamy, smooth mixes
- Flavors you won’t really get anywhere else in town
But the best part was actually how we ended up trying them.
We Tried a Blindfold Taste Test (and It Was Way Harder Than Expected)
When we went, one of the workers—Oakley—leaned all the way into the old-school vibe (white shirt, red apron, like the good old days) and made it fun right away.
He challenged my wife and me to a blindfold taste test of their sodas and ice cream and even offered a $15 gift card to my wife if she could guess the flavor of the most complicated soda.
She went for it… But it was way harder than it sounds.
She ended up getting about half of it right. At one point, she guessed coconut and raspberry, but it was actually coconut and huckleberry, which was so close.
Even when she was close, the flavors were just different enough to make it tricky.
The funny part is—she still loved every single one.
An Old-School Ice Cream Parlor in Rexburg
While she was working through the sodas, I went all in on the ice cream.
And honestly, everything I tried was really good.
They’ve got a mix of options like:
- Raspberry sorbet
- Dole Whip
- Grasshopper (a mix of mint, Oreo, and chocolate as a custard)
The variety surprised me—it’s not just basic flavors, and you can tell they’ve put thought into what they offer.
My favorite was easily the raspberry sorbet—and I actually guessed that one 100% right. It was lighter, super refreshing, and stood out from everything else. (Because my favorite flavor is always raspberry, but this was better than I expected, even being raspberry)
Why Rinky Dinks Stands Out in Rexburg
There are other places to get dessert in Rexburg, but none really hit this same combination.
What makes Rinky Dinks different is:
- It’s the only place with in-house homemade soda
- The flavors are actually unique (not just mixed syrups)
- The ice cream selection has a real variety
- Oh, and I forgot to mention before, they have the most amazing scones!
- The experience is fun, not just transactional
It’s not just a quick stop—it’s something you actually remember.
A Fun and Easy Spot for Any Night
Whether you’re:
- Out with friends
- On a date
- Just trying to find something to do
This place works.
It’s casual, easy, and you don’t have to plan much.
Honestly, doing something like the blind taste test made it way more fun than just grabbing dessert and leaving.
Where to Find This Soda Shop in Rexburg, Idaho
If you’re looking for a soda shop in Rexburg, Idaho that actually stands out, Rinky Dinks is easy to get to and worth checking out.
It’s also one of the newer spots in town, so not everyone knows about it yet.
Is Rinky Dinks Worth It?
Yeah—it is.
If you like:
- Unique drinks
- Trying new places
- Ice cream with real variety
Then it’s definitely worth going.
And if you get the chance, try the blindfold challenge—it’s harder than it looks.
Also, if you sign up for my email list and or mention this article when you go in, then they will give you a free Dole Whip if you send a dollar!
Final Thoughts
Rexburg doesn’t always get a lot of new or unique food spots, which is why this one stands out.
Between the only homemade soda in town, the old-school ice cream feel, and experiences like the taste test, it’s more than just a dessert stop.
It’s actually something fun to do in Rexburg.
